Brigadoon, Braveheart and the Scots: Distortions of Scotland by Colin McArthur

By Colin McArthur

This provocative booklet follows MGM's Gene Kelly musical Brigadoon during the worlds of Forties Broadway theatre and Nineteen Fifties Hollywood and files the contempt the movie has elicited, relatively from the Scots intelligentsia. McArthur succumbs to Brigadoon's attraction, yet reveals no such mitigating beneficial properties in Mel Gibson's 1995 blockbuster Braveheart . Tracing Braveheart 's appropriation through political, touristic and carrying figures, he argues that, faraway from its being approximately Scottish background, it's essentially approximately Hollywood's widespread varieties and cinematic traditions. He appears too on the method the movie distorts heritage and examines Braveheart 's sinister attract the proto-fascist psyche. McArthur argues that either motion pictures have huge, immense resonance inside Scottish tradition and the Scots diaspora and, crucially, for an unlimited around the globe viewers who can have no different wisdom of the Scots.

Show description

Read or Download Brigadoon, Braveheart and the Scots: Distortions of Scotland in Hollywood Cinema PDF

Similar film & television books

Newnes Guide to Television and Video Technology

Widespread diagrams and a few photographs are incorporated during this finished consultant to tv and video, with this variation now delivering the basics of electronic know-how. Trundle (he holds large British certification for television know-how) has designed his advisor for provider engineers and digital servicing scholars, directing them within the technical tactics serious about making those machines paintings.

Story and Discourse: Narrative Structure in Fiction and Film

Synthesizing the paintings of continental critics reminiscent of Genette, Todorov, and Barthes, and that of critics within the Anglo-American culture, reminiscent of Lubbock and sales space, Seymour Chatman offers a complete method of a normal idea of narrative, in either verbal and visible media. during this booklet, he analyzes what narrative is 'in itself.

The Archaeology of Hollywood: Traces of the Golden Age

The Golden Age of Hollywood, relationship to the hazy depths of the early twentieth Century, used to be an period of motion picture stars worshipped via the hundreds and despotic studio moguls issuing decrees from poolside divans… yet regardless of the world-wide succeed in of the motion picture undefined, little greater than stories of that period linger amidst the freeways and condo complexes of today’s la.

Literature, Film, and Their Hideous Progeny: Adaptation and ElasTEXTity

This booklet posits variations as 'hideous progeny,' Mary Shelley's time period for her novel, Frankenstein . Like Shelley's novel and her fictional Creature, diversifications which could first be visible as sizeable in reality compel us to shift our point of view on recognized literary or movie works and the cultures that gave upward push to them.

Additional info for Brigadoon, Braveheart and the Scots: Distortions of Scotland in Hollywood Cinema

Example text

Given that Lewis’ involvement in Brigadoon might be seen as the coming to fruition of all these qualities which the Group inhibited, it is a pleasing coincidence that one of his earliest muscle-flexings as director should have been the William Saroyan play of 1939 – My Heart’s in the Highlands. Agnes De Mille and Oliver Smith Of the three pairs in the photographs with which I began, Lerner and Loewe already occupied the popular terrain of Broadway (although Loewe would get there by way of the tradition of European classical music), Cheryl Crawford and Robert Lewis would get there by way of leftwing theatre and De Mille and Smith would arrive via the High Art of classical ballet and ‘legitimate’ theatre.

Maxine Sullivan executed a very popular swing version of ‘Loch Lomond’, as did Martha Tilton, the Benny Goodman Band vocalist, at the famous 1938 Goodman concert at Carnegie Hall, while Ella Fitzgerald might include an extempore phrase from a Scottish song in an otherwise ‘straight’ swing number – for example, from ‘Comin’ Through the Rye’ (which itself got the jazzed-up treatment as ‘Swingin’ through the Rye) in ‘Sing Me a Swing Song’ – and even recorded an entire ‘Scottish’ novelty number – ‘Macpherson is Rehearsin’.

The rubric under which these tendencies then operated was ‘patriotism’. The sombre subtext to our story is the McCarthyite purges of the Cold War, which would drive underground this progressive conception of patriotism. Indeed, many of those on the left who had been most alert to the danger of fascism in the 1930s would be denounced during the Cold War as ‘premature anti-fascists’. A full account of the turn to the socially-conscious vernacular would have to deal with the crucial influence of certain federal government mechanisms such as the Federal Arts Project, the Federal Music Project, the Federal Theater Project and the Federal Writers Project which boldly mobilised ‘creative’ personnel into publicly-funded work on much the same basis as plumbers, carpenters and bricklayers.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.79 of 5 – based on 11 votes